I don't think I've ever
heard this possibility/consideration: that music is, or can be considered, a
language. Or if I have, its been a while since I gave it thought.
Thinking about it the last few days, I believe it is a language.
This said from someone who studied and learned languages: I'm fluent in
Spanish, and studied Russian for a few years (not fluent since I didn't and
don't use it). It sounds kinda funny, "music is a
language," but it rings true: music is something that we learn
to read, "speak" (sing) and write...same as we do a language. I
think music can be learned, with training and study, however, I think some of
us have an easier time of it, and it comes more naturally (talent?), than
others. I've always heard, or learned (not sure of the source?) that some
of us have an easier time with languages (music, too?), and others do well
with math & science. I'm a music/language person for sure. I'm
not particularly fond of math & science (like I am with languages,
music, "the arts")...but I'm capable. Math and science
don't come "naturally" and require a lot more of my attention,
focus & study. But music? I can get by reading it and get
a general understanding (depending on the simpllicity of the piece), but I
wouldn't consider myself "fluent." I can see and understand
notes going up & down, and +/- understand rests and timing, but there's a
lot more I don't know, and since I can't write music, I don't
consider myself "fluent." My ability to sing doesn't come from
training, I never studied it. I took piano lessons for only bout 6
months as a child...and 3-4 months as an adult a few years back...so maybe
this helps with my "kinda-ability" to
read music. Singing to me comes naturally; it may be in my
genes since many in my family are also musically-inclined.
Saturday, December 3, 2011
Thursday, December 1, 2011
Marisa
Music is a language. It is used to convey thoughts, feelings, and emotions, usually at a higher level than a word language. Music is often what we turn to when the need for expression is so great that no other language can capture what you are trying to say.
Michael
1. I
do not, as music generally utilizes other languages already, and without using
these languages it would be difficult for music to convey concepts of any
complexity.
2. the syntax of it, if you will. The methods of reading it, and the way you can combine individually learned concepts or ideas in music to create a general impression, much the same way languages do, but again, less complex
3. I have taken 5 years of piano, and know how to read music. I might have expanded a bit beyond piano, into guitar or drums.
4. At the moment, nothing.
5. I am happy with my ability to read and understand music.
6. I can read all but the most complicated musical pieces, and, for piano, play them after practicing for a bit, however, I cannot compose (well, I physically can, but I do not have the imagination to compose anything that sounds even somewhat adequate).
7. I believe a lot of reading and speaking is training more than talent, although talent helps you to progress faster, and composing is more talent, with training just fleshing it out, as it were.
8. upside down smiley face?
2. the syntax of it, if you will. The methods of reading it, and the way you can combine individually learned concepts or ideas in music to create a general impression, much the same way languages do, but again, less complex
3. I have taken 5 years of piano, and know how to read music. I might have expanded a bit beyond piano, into guitar or drums.
4. At the moment, nothing.
5. I am happy with my ability to read and understand music.
6. I can read all but the most complicated musical pieces, and, for piano, play them after practicing for a bit, however, I cannot compose (well, I physically can, but I do not have the imagination to compose anything that sounds even somewhat adequate).
7. I believe a lot of reading and speaking is training more than talent, although talent helps you to progress faster, and composing is more talent, with training just fleshing it out, as it were.
8. upside down smiley face?
Brooke
1. Do you think music should be considered a
language? Explain why or why not
Based on the definition of language, I would have to consider it a language. It is formalized sound that conveys emotions or thoughts. And in a way, music has its own dialects with various instruments. It can be learned, but my one trouble spot is whether or not music can explain music. That is, can one "say" something in music that another can reply to with not just an emotional response, but a "verbal" one as well, so long as both parties understand music. After all, you can gather a Spanish speaker is angry by tone even if you don't know the language, but if you do, you can understand the purpose of the anger and respond to it with words to calm that person down. I'm not 100% positive music can do that, unless you're combining a spoken language through voice, Even then, though, I feel like the words themselves don't carry as much of the meaning of the song as the tone. So, if music is a language, then it is a very unique one because it is very dependant on the tone of the entire piece to convey everything, rather than the notes themselves which you could consider words.
2. What aspects of learning music make it similar to learning a language? Be specific.
For one, learning the sounds that go with each note is very similar to learning the sound that goes with words or letters. For another, there is a certain grammar to music and certain structure and order in which you read music. Practicing music is also important in solidifying the knowledge in the same way you must practice using a language.
Based on the definition of language, I would have to consider it a language. It is formalized sound that conveys emotions or thoughts. And in a way, music has its own dialects with various instruments. It can be learned, but my one trouble spot is whether or not music can explain music. That is, can one "say" something in music that another can reply to with not just an emotional response, but a "verbal" one as well, so long as both parties understand music. After all, you can gather a Spanish speaker is angry by tone even if you don't know the language, but if you do, you can understand the purpose of the anger and respond to it with words to calm that person down. I'm not 100% positive music can do that, unless you're combining a spoken language through voice, Even then, though, I feel like the words themselves don't carry as much of the meaning of the song as the tone. So, if music is a language, then it is a very unique one because it is very dependant on the tone of the entire piece to convey everything, rather than the notes themselves which you could consider words.
2. What aspects of learning music make it similar to learning a language? Be specific.
For one, learning the sounds that go with each note is very similar to learning the sound that goes with words or letters. For another, there is a certain grammar to music and certain structure and order in which you read music. Practicing music is also important in solidifying the knowledge in the same way you must practice using a language.
3. Describe your musical training. What would you
have changed in your training, if anything, to help yourself become more
“fluent” in music?
Through middle school and the beginning of high school I had formal vocal training through choir and other teachers. I first really learned how to read music by piano, solidified by training on the violin for a year. If I were to change anything, it would be that I had simply practiced and utilized music more. I also would have loved to learn with more than just two instruments how to read music.
4. What are you planning on doing in the future to further your musical literacy?
I want to learn how to actually play the piano and drums, but otherwise the closest I will get to musical literacy is a continuation in musical theater and a greater exposure to different music tracks for pleasure.
Through middle school and the beginning of high school I had formal vocal training through choir and other teachers. I first really learned how to read music by piano, solidified by training on the violin for a year. If I were to change anything, it would be that I had simply practiced and utilized music more. I also would have loved to learn with more than just two instruments how to read music.
4. What are you planning on doing in the future to further your musical literacy?
I want to learn how to actually play the piano and drums, but otherwise the closest I will get to musical literacy is a continuation in musical theater and a greater exposure to different music tracks for pleasure.
5. How fluent would you like to become?
You know how some people slip in and out of a language in normal speech or when their on the phone and its very confusing for everyone around them? I want to be that person. Wishful thinking.
6. Describe the different aspects of your musical literacy: reading, speaking (performing or playing), and/or writing (composing). I'm pretty good at reading, at least of the type that I know. Better at performing, at least vocally, because I can feel it; and shit at composing, unless you count making up songs on the spot about how I can't find my keys or shoes.
7. How much of musical talent do you believe is training? How much do you believe is talent?
I think most of it comes from training. Just like people have a proclivity to languages and can learn faster than others, so too for music. Whether or not someone communicates very well comes from a combination of hard work and desire to be successful. Talent can speed the process up, but I think anyone with enough drive can get there, theoretically.
You know how some people slip in and out of a language in normal speech or when their on the phone and its very confusing for everyone around them? I want to be that person. Wishful thinking.
6. Describe the different aspects of your musical literacy: reading, speaking (performing or playing), and/or writing (composing). I'm pretty good at reading, at least of the type that I know. Better at performing, at least vocally, because I can feel it; and shit at composing, unless you count making up songs on the spot about how I can't find my keys or shoes.
7. How much of musical talent do you believe is training? How much do you believe is talent?
I think most of it comes from training. Just like people have a proclivity to languages and can learn faster than others, so too for music. Whether or not someone communicates very well comes from a combination of hard work and desire to be successful. Talent can speed the process up, but I think anyone with enough drive can get there, theoretically.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)